In post-2014 India, the state’s strategic deployment of disinformation, judicial opacity, and media spectacle has rendered truth both criminalized and performative. This paper interrogates the paradox of demanding a Truth and Accountability Commission from institutions deeply embedded in untruth. Drawing on Michel Foucault’s critique of confession, Derrida’s concept of archive fever, Freud’s metaphor of the mystic pad, Arendt’s theorization of lying in politics, and Guattari’s notion of pseudology, we propose the “mystique pad” as an insurgent counter-archive. Anchored in the empirical landscape of electoral manipulation, SLAPP suits, RTI evasions, and media censorship in India (2014–2025), the paper posits that civil society’s imperative is no longer merely revelation—but memorialization. Truth, in this schema, is not the opposite of falsehood but its residue.