The article critically assesses Chief Justice Chandrachud’s legacy, emphasizing its contradictions. While he is praised for apparently being “progressive”, his tenure is also marred by decisions that seem to align with the present ruling party of India, the BJP. It discusses his ambivalence in upholding the secular constitutional values versus religion-oriented actions that favor the crony oligarchical as well as religious extremist establishment. The piece highlights his complex role in balancing judicial independence with executive influence, casting doubt on the long-term impact of his legacy.